November 16, 2026 · 7 min read

How to pick an Instagram giveaway winner fairly

A giveaway is only good for your account if entrants believe it was fair. That comes down to three things: clear rules before you start, a random draw anyone can check, and a quick verification before you announce.

1. Write the rules first

  • How to enter: for example, comment with the name of a friend who'd love this. Keep it to one action plus, at most, one tag requirement.
  • Deadline with a time zone: closes Sunday 23:59 ET.
  • Who can enter: age and countries. Shipping and local law usually decide this.
  • One entry per person or multiple: say which. One per person is easier to verify.
  • How the winner is chosen and announced: random draw from eligible comments, announced in stories within 48 hours, winner has 72 hours to reply.
  • A line saying the promotion isn't sponsored, endorsed or administered by Instagram. Instagram's promotion guidelines require it, along with official rules.

2. Draw from the comments

  1. After the deadline, copy the post link and paste it into Combly's Instagram comment picker.
  2. Apply exactly the rules you published: tags required, one entry per person, a keyword if you asked for one.
  3. Exclude your account, co-hosts and staff.
  4. Choose one winner and two backups, then draw. Share the winner page so entrants can see the rules, the number of qualifying entries and the draw time.

3. Verify before you announce

Follower status, likes and story shares aren't public data, so no picker can check them honestly. Open the winner's profile and check those yourself. If they don't qualify, move to the first backup and say so in your announcement.

Message the winner from your real account, and remind followers you'll never ask for payment or card details. Impersonator accounts often message entrants pretending they won.

Legal basics (not legal advice)

  • In the US, a giveaway is generally lawful when entry is free: a prize plus chance plus a required purchase can make it an illegal lottery. Don't require a purchase to enter.
  • Some countries and states have registration or bonding rules for large prizes. Check if your prize is valuable.
  • Don't ask people to tag themselves in photos they're not in; Instagram's guidelines forbid inaccurate tagging.

Instagram comment picker

Free Instagram giveaway picker: draw a random winner from a post or reel's comments, require tags or a hashtag, one entry per person, and share a winner page.

Open the free tool

FAQ

More guides